As a freshman in high school, Elliott Kurta, one of my first student guest bloggers, is pretty busy with his academic workload and volunteer work at the library. But he returns to my blog today with a book he genuinely enjoyed, Down to Earth by Betty Culley.
REVIEW
In Down to Earth, Henry Bower, an aspiring scientist, and water dowser, witnesses a meteorite fall from the sky and land in his backyard. Henry, his sister Birdie, and his best friend, James, are at first in awe of the gigantic, space-borne stone. But soon, as the meteorite draws attention around his rural Maine town from the press and the scientific community alike, the meteorite is cast in a negative light. A gushing river has spouted near where the meteorite has landed, forcing the Bower family to evacuate their home, and all of the wells in town have begun to run dry. As the community begins to turn on the Bowers, Henry finds his voice to stand up to what he knows to be right. Aided by his sister, parents, best friend, and a genteel museum curator, the meteorite inspires Henry to find his place in the world.
Henry, the intrepid protagonist of the novel, is without a doubt the heart of the story. His curiosity and earnestness serve to heighten the story; this novel is worth reading for his narration alone. One example of Henry’s simultaneously warm and analytical voice is his use of percentages to measure his emotions as he tries to work through his conflicting feelings. Henry’s narration is light-hearted but realistic, even as the townspeople become disgruntled that Henry’s family happened to recover the meteorite, for which a large reward has been offered. Despite the optimism expressed by the Bowers throughout the novel, the arrival of the meteorite is foreshadowed by tragedy, as the Bowers lose their home early in the story due to flooding caused by the meteorite’s landing.
An important, recurring element in Down to Earth is the connection Henry and his family share with nature. Henry has grown up watching his mother forage for food in the nearby forest, collecting fiddleheads and cattails. His father is a dowser, and works alongside his brother, Henry’s uncle, to drill wells for the townspeople. The deep respect Henry feels for the natural world can be seen when he first greets the meteorite, on page 24.
I want to say something to the big rock myself, to welcome it the way my parents make visitors, or even strangers, feel at home. Then I remember what my mother says when she finds a mushroom or fern she can’t identify.
“I don’t know your name, but I’m glad to meet you,” I say to the big rock.
Down to Earth is written for the natural scientist in each of us, and recaptures the wonders of childhood while at the same time showing Henry’s journey as he finds his place in the world. Henry’s optimism and respect for the natural world around him serve to root the story, and his narration makes even the most prosaic of things—such as a seemingly ordinary rock—take on a new life. The novel, through Henry’s exuberant narration and the coincidences that lead Henry to discover his voice, makes a powerful case for living life down to earth.
 |
| Elliott is a prolific reader of various genres who is more than happy to share his opinions on books. In his free time, he enjoys writing, reading, and running. He is a 9th-grade student in Charlotte, NC. |
GIVEAWAY
I know two of my grands that would love this!! Thanks for sharing.Hewi Mason
I'll start the list with your name, Hewi. Glad to see your message went through this time.
This is a book already on my wish list. I think the review is superb and reminded me how much I also want to read this book.
Good Job Elliott! Aren't young people amazing!
Happy to add your name to the giveaway list, Danielle. Yes, Elliott is a superb writer!
Yes, Terri. I love my young reviewers!
I seriously could not be so eloquent. Fantastic review, Elliot. I hadn't heard of this book, and I'm glad I know about it now. I visit Maine sometimes, so the setting appeals to me. I definitely want to read this one!
Thanks, Theresa. I'm sure Elliott will bust his buttons when reading your reaction to his review.
Dear Carol and Elliott,Great job! Seems like “Down to Earth” is a good down to earth book!Sincerely,Joan
Thanks, Joan. I agree!!
As always, great review, Elliott! I hadn't heard of this book before, but it sounds great!
Thanks, Marci, for commenting and encouraging Elliott. I'll add your name to the list.
I am amazed at Elliott's review writing. Glad to know even high school students read MG novels. I hope Elliott continues to enjoy writing. He has a talent, engaging his readers.
Thank you, Beth. Can you please identify yourself for the giveaway? I need your email address to enter you.
Great review as always, Elliot, and an interesting premise for a story, thanks for sharing!
Thanks for the fantastic review, Elliott. I'm going to pass on the giveaway because I already have too many books to read.
Thanks Natalie and Valinora!
I don't need a copy, but do want to give a thumbs up for this review. It is a fun book to read.
Thank you, Sue!
Sounds interesting. Henry sounds like someone you can root for!
I'll add your name to the giveaway list, Maria. Thanks for commenting.
I recently read The Natural Genius of Ants by Betty Culley—a brilliant book about a father reconnecting with his two boys and finding his way back after losing a baby as a doctor.
No need to put my name in the hat. I have read this wonderful book and loved it. What a terrific review! Thanks, Elliott. Great job.
Thanks for leaving a comment, Pete and for the recommendation. Can you provide your email address so I can enter your name in the giveaway?
I know two of my grands that would love this!! Thanks for sharing.Hewi Mason
I'll start the list with your name, Hewi. Glad to see your message went through this time.
This is a book already on my wish list. I think the review is superb and reminded me how much I also want to read this book.
Good Job Elliott! Aren't young people amazing!
Happy to add your name to the giveaway list, Danielle. Yes, Elliott is a superb writer!
Yes, Terri. I love my young reviewers!
I seriously could not be so eloquent. Fantastic review, Elliot. I hadn't heard of this book, and I'm glad I know about it now. I visit Maine sometimes, so the setting appeals to me. I definitely want to read this one!
Thanks, Theresa. I'm sure Elliott will bust his buttons when reading your reaction to his review.
Dear Carol and Elliott,Great job! Seems like “Down to Earth” is a good down to earth book!Sincerely,Joan
Thanks, Joan. I agree!!
As always, great review, Elliott! I hadn't heard of this book before, but it sounds great!
Thanks, Marci, for commenting and encouraging Elliott. I'll add your name to the list.
I am amazed at Elliott's review writing. Glad to know even high school students read MG novels. I hope Elliott continues to enjoy writing. He has a talent, engaging his readers.
Thank you, Beth. Can you please identify yourself for the giveaway? I need your email address to enter you.
Great review as always, Elliot, and an interesting premise for a story, thanks for sharing!
Thanks for the fantastic review, Elliott. I'm going to pass on the giveaway because I already have too many books to read.
Thanks Natalie and Valinora!
I don't need a copy, but do want to give a thumbs up for this review. It is a fun book to read.
Thank you, Sue!
Sounds interesting. Henry sounds like someone you can root for!
I'll add your name to the giveaway list, Maria. Thanks for commenting.
I recently read The Natural Genius of Ants by Betty Culley—a brilliant book about a father reconnecting with his two boys and finding his way back after losing a baby as a doctor.
No need to put my name in the hat. I have read this wonderful book and loved it. What a terrific review! Thanks, Elliott. Great job.
Thanks for leaving a comment, Pete and for the recommendation. Can you provide your email address so I can enter your name in the giveaway?